From the brink of disaster ....

Today I am wondering if I need to re-title my blog.   I think this might need to be called "Salvaging Dessert" or "How to Hide Your Dessert Mistakes."

For Christmas Caleb got me a "Big Top Cupcake Pan."   Yes, it is what it sounds like - a pan that lets you make a giant cupcake.   It also has a piece that you can put onto the top of the bottom section of the pan which will let you put a filling into the cake.   I'd describe it more, but if you can't picture it and don't know what I'm talking about you can check out their website .... https://www.bigtopcupcake.com/?MID=626698

Anyway, Caleb has been asking me to make one since he gave it to me on Christmas so today I decided to make one.   According to the instructions you should be able to make one with just one cake mix, so I decided that I would make one with a white cake mix, fill it with chocolate pudding and then frost it with a homemade whipped frosing.    So I mixed up the white cake mix and filled the bottom pan and the top pan, and placed them into the oven to "bake as directed".    After about 20 or 25 minutes I checked on them and as the directions indicated it appeared that the top part had finished baking even though the bottom part was not yet done.   I put a toothpick in it and it came out clean so I took it out of the oven.   So far, so good.

After another 15 or 20 minutes I checked on the bottom part, put a toothpick in it, found it was done and took it out of the oven.    While I was waiting for this part to cool I thought I should get the top part out of the pan onto a wire rack to cool.   When I turned it over to dump it out it came out of the pan beautifully, however, the top part (which had been the bottom of the pan) was still completely runny.   It was as if I had created a "cake bowl" with cake soup in it.   Very tasty, but there was no way that I was going to be able to put it on top of the bottom part of the cupcake.    So into the trash it went.

Since I didn't have another white cake mix I had to figure out how to salvage this giant cupcake and my son's image of his mother as dessert-maker.   I decided that I would change the plan and have a white bottom half and chocolate top half as I had a chocolate cake mix in the pantry.   However, I knew that there was no way that I needed the entire cake mix just for the top of this cupcake and I hated the idea of throwing away cake mix or cake batter.   This led to the next step in the salvaging dessert plan.   I measured the cake mix (there are 3 cups of cake mix in a box) and used just 2/3 of the cake mix, with just 2/3 of the eggs, oil and water called for.   I poured it into the top part of the cupcake pan and put it in the oven to bake -- this time with the oven set at 325 instead of 350 so that it could hopefully cook all the way through this time.  

I mixed up the whipped frosting and then took out about a cup of this frosting and mixed it with the remaining cake batter and used this as the filling instead of the chocolate pudding.  The filling was delicious.   Unfortunately the temperature of my kitchen appliances got the better of me again in my frosting.   The frosting recipe calls for margarine and shortening to be mixed together.   I needed to soften the margarine and my super powerful microwave melted most of it.   I mixed the shortening and margarine for a bit and then put them in the freezer for a few minutes, but should have done it a little bit longer to keep the frosting cooler.   It tasted delicious but was a bit to soft and runny for frosting the side of the cake.

Lessons learned .... the cake, however, was delicious and requests have been made by Caleb for another one soon!  

Reviews from the family ....
Mark and I loved the frosting, but Caleb was not a fan.   Caleb, however, really liked the cake parts and loved the filling (even after we told him it was made from the same ingredients as the frosting.)

Whipped Frosting Recipe:

Ingredients

• 4 tablespoons all-purpose flour
• 1 cup skim milk
• 1/2 cup butter-flavor shortening
• 1/2 cup margarine
• 1 cup sugar
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract

Directions

1. In a small saucepan, mix milk into flour gradually to prevent lumps. Cook, stirring constantly over low heat until thick. Remove from heat and stir until cooled.
2. In mixer bowl, combine shortening and slightly softened (not melted!) margarine, beat 4 minutes. Add sugar; beat 4 minutes. Add cooled paste and vanilla and beat well.